Last Updated: 22nd September 2026
16 Most Amazing Butt Plugs According To Reviews
We've compiled a list of the 16 Most Amazing Butt Plugs According To Reviews - September 2026. We put them through their paces to bring you this list of the best on the market.
# 16 Si Novelties - $29.95
Si Novelties Large Penis Butt Plug 6.5 Inch By Si Novelties
Shaped to satisfy with a lifelike shaft and bulbous head, this realistic butt plug is a satisfying 6.5 inches in length with a fulfilling 4.75 girth. Coat it with lashings of anal lube and embark on an orgasmic anal adventure, alone or with your lover.
# 15 Tracey Cox - $22.95
Tracey Cox Supersex Beginner's Butt Plug By Tracey Cox
Beginner-friendly, flexible silicone butt plug with tapered tip and flared base, includes anal play guide, submersible and body-safe.
# 14 Lovehoney - $44.95
Lovehoney Full Bloom Small Rose Glass Butt Plug 3.5 Inch By Lovehoney
Forget a bouquet: with this small, sensual glass butt plug, you only need a single rose to impress. Delicately carved from borosilicate glass with a slim neck and filling 3.75 inch girth, plant this plug in your back garden for splendid pleasure.
# 13 Lovehoney - $19.97
Lovehoney Bedtime Bullet 10 Function Vibrating Butt Plug 4 Inch By Lovehoney
Here's an ideal choice for anal play beginners seeking an extra buzz from their butt plug. It may be petite in size, but the 7 intense patterns and 3 speeds will put an arch in your back and add an extra 'oh-my' to your orgasms.
# 12 Cock Locker - $64.95
Cock Locker Inflatable Penis Butt Plug 6 Inch By Cock Locker
Explore customizable anal play with the Cock Locker Inflatable Penis Butt Plug 6 Inch. This latex toy inflates from 5 to 12 inches in girth, offering realistic aesthetics and adjustable fullness for personalized comfort and sensation.
# 11 Lovehoney BASICS - $7.98
BASICS Slimline P-Spot Butt Plug By Lovehoney BASICS
Flexible PVC P-spot butt plug with flared and suction bases, designed for beginner anal play and prostate stimulation.
# 10 Lovehoney - $29.95
Lovehoney Super Soft Silicone Rainbow Butt Plug By Lovehoney
Flexible, waterproof silicone butt plug with a strong suction cup for hands-free play, featuring a beginner-friendly size and vibrant rainbow colors.
# 9 Doc Johnson - $29.95
Doc Johnson Mood Naughty Small Silicone Butt Plug By Doc Johnson
Tempted by the exciting prospect of anal play but don't quite know where to start? This little butt plug is the anal toy for you. Petite with a velvety-soft, silicone body, it slips in with ease for extra thrills during solo play, foreplay and sex.
# 8 nsnovelties - $27.47
Jelly Rancher Pleasure Anal Training Butt Plug Kit (3 Piece) By nsnovelties
3-piece soft plastic anal training kit with flared bases, suction cups, and progressive sizes for safe, beginner-friendly butt play.
# 7 Cock Locker - $79.95
Cock Locker Large Inflatable Butt Plug 7.5 Inch By Cock Locker
The Cock Locker Large Inflatable Butt Plug uses durable latex and a bulb pump to expand from 6.25 to 14.75 inches in girth. Ideal for progressive stretching, it offers customizable fullness and a flexible, coreless design for intense sensory play.
# 6 Mantric - $84.95
Mantric Rechargeable Vibrating Butt Plug By Mantric
Rechargeable, waterproof, silicone butt plug with multiple vibrations, color-changing controls, and a secure flared base for safe, intense anal pleasure.
# 5 TitanMen - $44.95
Doc Johnson TitanMen Master Tool No.4 Butt Plug 6 Inch By TitanMen
The Doc Johnson TitanMen Master Tool No.4 is an extra-large, firm PVC butt plug for experienced users. Featuring three progressively girthy bulbs up to 8.25 inches and a 6-inch insertable length, it offers intense stretching and fullness with a safe, flared base.
# 4 TitanMen - $44.95
Doc Johnson Titanmen The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug 6.5 Inch By TitanMen
The Doc Johnson Titanmen The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug is a large, non-vibrating PVC anal toy with a 6.5-inch insertable length and 7-inch circumference. It features a realistic phallic head, a bulbous shaft for prostate stimulation, and a flared base for safety.
# 3 Lelo - $292.99
Lelo Loki Wave Rechargeable 7.7" Prostate Massager By Lelo
The Lelo Loki Wave is a premium, rechargeable prostate massager featuring WaveMotion technology for a unique 'come-hither' motion combined with 10 vibration settings and dual internal/external stimulation.
# 2 Lovehoney - $69.95
Lovehoney Get Started Beginner's Anal Kit (4 Piece) By Lovehoney
Explore anal play safely with the Lovehoney Get Started Beginner's Anal Kit (4 Piece). This set includes a butt plug, probe, vibrating beads, and vibrating plug, all featuring tapered tips and flared bases for easy, secure insertion.
# 1 Lovehoney - $47.45
Lovehoney Jewelled Metal Medium Butt Plug 3 Inch By Lovehoney
Experience firm, weighty stimulation with the Lovehoney Jewelled Metal Medium Butt Plug. This 3-inch zinc alloy plug features a sparkling gem base, temperature play capability, and a 4.5-inch girth for deep, satisfying fullness.